Review of Wikia Search Engine
Jimmy Wales the creator of Wikipedia has recently launched the alpha release of his search engine called Wikia Search. There have been several reviews posted on the Internet, so i thought why not i chip in with my own thoughts. Ok before I give you might thought, allow me to share with you what some of the other experts reviewers & bloggers have said about Wikia Search. The first review i read was from Techmeme, and according to them ‘Wikia Search is complete letdown’. Then I read Tony Ruscoe’s post in GoogleBlogoscoped, and guess what? …Tony wasn’t very please either!
Now here goes my thoughts:
Initially I thought Wikia Search is going to feed their result page with all ‘wiki results’ or at least they will only give high preference to the Wiki results. Anyway so I began searching and figured i was wrong, there was ‘fair amount of’ other results. But were they ‘relevant’? Were they what i was actually ‘looking for’?
Well, the answer is NO. I didn’t even go close to what I was looking for. For instance, I searched for “Las Vegas Series“, and the first few results was full of links of Las Vegas- City, Hotels, Resorts etc! But I was just looking for this! And guess where this appeared…..In number 8! I also ran into some HTTP Status 500 errors when trying to view cached pages, so itâ€™s not just the quality of the search results thatâ€™s low, I believe there are some technical glitch too!
Of course you might argue that, its too early to tell as it has been there only for a day. Well i certainly agree! However I believe due to the massive popularity of search engine giants like Google & Yahoo and the quality of the results which they produce; Its simply impossible for any company to come up with a search engine and get loyal users without coming up with a ‘top class’ product at this point of time. Because there is simply too much competition out there, and people are better off searching in
Google & Yahoo rather than trying out a new search engine like Wikia Search, and be disappointed with the quality of their result.
And they themselves admit it:
â€œWe are aware that the quality of the search results is low.â€
â€“ The Wikia Search About Us page.